Why do we need to fund the arts in the first place?

And why is there never enough?

(and why that is not, in the end, an arts problem)

As we roll into the budget announcement I wanted to ask a question before the annual disappointment lands.

Why does the state bother to fund the arts at all?

I mean, in a very literal sense, why do we need to fund them, in the very specific, almost mechanical sense of what is the money actually paying for? What problem is it fixing?

Now, what usually happens at this point is the conversation takes a bit of a diversion and we start talking about “Intrinsic Value” “Public Good” “Merit” and in recent years “Wellbeing” “Soft Power” etc. And even sometimes we can offer “Market Failure” as the answer. Now I’ve used all of these answers and arguments in various reports, blogs, workshops, policy briefs and so on, and they are all valuable and useful from their particular perspectives.

However, if I’m completely honest I think they’re more a set of values than actual answers. (and I suspect that very few policy makers actually believe them). I say this because there is an answer to the question that is very very simple:

We fund the arts because most people couldn’t afford to pay for them if the price reflected the actual cost of production

Performance is a great example here. Ask yourself what a ticket to a show in your local arts centre would cost if the ticket price reflected the full cost of production – the artists’ time, the building cost, the staff costs, the marketing, the set materials, the construction costs, the light, the heat, etc. All tickets would start somewhere around the €200 mark. And if it’s not Oasis nobody is willing – or able – to pay that price. The actual real price for an arts experience would literally emtpty the theatre and almost everywhere would close down.

What we call “Subsidy” is simply the name we give to the way we try to close the gap between the price people can pay and the real cost of producing the work.

When we consider the nature of that gap the whole arts economy/funding system starts to make sense, and we can understand and explain the thing that everybody complains about: why there is never, ever, enough funding. As one politician remarked to a colleage recently, “Sure you lot have a load of increases these last few years”.

Unfortunately for everybody – including this politician – the gap between affordable price and true cost is not stable, and so its not something that the arts sector might one day close through efficiency, or better “audience engagement” or marketing, or a bit of business support or an entrepreneurial mindset. The gap is being widened constantly at both ends by economic forces outside the control of the arts sector.

From one side of the gap, the price most of the public can afford to pay is falling in real terms. On a global scale wages have not tracked inflation and – as we know – housing, energy and childcare have eaten what disposable income remains for many people. The “affordable ticket price” is for an increasing number of people a smaller and smaller number every year because they have less disposable income in real terms.

And on the other side of the gap the cost of production rises inexorably – with general inflation, hypercharged by the economic phenomenon of Cost Disease.

What this means is that most artistic labour cannot get the productivity gains the rest of the economy relies on to hold prices down. It takes the same number of musicians the same length of time to play a concerto as it did a century ago; imagining the novel or the play or the poem still takes whatever time it takes, likewise the painting or the scupture or the installation. Productivity gains in this kind of labour are marginal at best. In creative labour the artist is both the principal input and the principle process. This is Baumol’s Cost Disease (Baumol & Bowen, 1966), and its impact is unavoidable:

The arts become structurally more expensive relative to everything else forever, as a matter of arithmetic – despite how well managed they are.

So the gap between what the work costs and the price people can afford to pay is widening from both ends at once all the time. And that means that the subsidy required to bridge that gap gets bigger all the time. There is nothing here that the Department or the Arts Council or the sector can do to control a set of macroeconomic conditions – stagnant wages, rising prices, and rising inequality. And that is why there is never, ever enough. We keep expecting an arts budget to pay for a wealth-redistribution/inequalty/inflation problem, and that problem keeps getting bigger moment by moment, year on year.

Now we all know that the “subsidy” – when it arrives – is never, ever capable of bridging the gap between the actual cost of production and the price that can be paid, and that means that a second subsidy is required.

So, when public funding does not bridge the gap – and remember that standstill (or below the rate of inflation) funding, in a period of inflation, guarantees it will not – the shortfall does not vanish. Some things don’t happen but overall the shortfall is made up by people whose contribution never appears as a line in any budget: the artists and arts workers themselves, through fees below the minimum wage, through unpaid preparation, through deferred and foregone income, through salaries that haven’t increased in years, through increased responsibilities etc. All this free labour fills the ever-growing subsidy gap. (Interestingly the same thing happens in education, in child care, elder care, in any sector that depends primarily on people)

But we all know about the hidden subsidy – it’s a core principle in the economics of artistic labour. The arts sector is known to be an “exceptional” economy in which an oversupplied, intrinsically motivated workforce accepts systematically low and uncertain returns (see Abbing’s Why are Artists Poor, 2002 and Menger’s The Economics of Creativity 2014). Fobazi Ettarh coined the term “Vocational Awe” in 2018 (Vocational Awe and Librarianship: The Lies We Tell Ourselves) to explain the phenomenon of people who believe the work they do is so essential that that they absorb the additional costs of production into themselves. If we do that then there’s no pressing need for the state to address the subsidy gap.

We tend to think of this hidden subsidy as a characteristic of the arts labour market. But given that its a “characteristic” that is growing in size we can suggest that the poverty expereienced by artists and the fragility experienced by arts organisations are not regrettable side-effects of the funding system. They are a funding mechanism.

What I mean by this is that the hidden subsidy that generates the sectors prevailing poverty is used as the sector’s balancing item (in an accounting sense), the invisible transfer closes the funding gap and balances the books as it were. The same way it does in care, and housework, and other structurally similar sectors.

Now we have a really clear picture of the arts funding system.

On the demand side what the public can pay is falling so ticket prices cannot rise; on the supply side the cost of making the work continues to rise above the standard riate of inflation. The gap between these two poles is filled by two subsidies: the public one (e.g. an Arts Council Budget) , and the private one which is extracted from the workforce. If we continue to hold the public subsidy flat in real terms the gap widens every year. However the system still has to “clear” so it consumes the only variable left free to move – the income of the people working in the sector. It’s no surprise that the Department’s research into BIA found deprivation levels 3 times the national average.

Standstill funding is not neutral. At its heart it is a political decision about how much additional poverty the people who work in the sector will be required to absorb to keep the sector functioning.

Essentially a single under-costed subsidy is being asked to do three incompatible things at once: keep the artist alive, cover the cost of production, and keep the cost of access affordable to the public. None of these functions is resourced to meet their actual costs because they’ve become all tangled up in everybody’s mind. If we can untangle it the policy choices become clearer

Artist livelihood is an income/welfare question and should sit with social protection and a payment scheme open to all creative workers modelled on something like the farm assist scheme should be put in place.

Production is a supply-side question and funding needs to meet the true cost of making the work, so the output costs need to be priced realistically (if you funded everything 100% then the state could earn all the PAYE, VAT etc, and could take some or all of the value of sales back)

Access is a demand-side question and the cost of access needs to be minimised, and Sen’s capability approach needs to be taken so we can identify real barriers to access and deal with them.

If we fund each function then we can stop balancing the books by extracting more free labour from the people who work in the sector.

Will this require a bigger subsidy? Absolutely! It’s worth saying that the idea that a state subsidy is a cost to be minimised, especially on “non essential services”, is an ideological position. As Mazzucato (2018) and many, many others have argued: state subsidy creates value in its own right (the Department’s own reseach on BIA clearly established this)

So, when the budget drops and news of arts council funding is announced, remember two questions that matter.

Which of the three jobs is this money pretending to do?

And: whose poverty is making up the difference?

We can ask the same questions about a whole range of human centred sectors dependent on subsidy and held together by invisible labour (and its worth doing that)

From a policy perspective putting more money into a poorly designed system does not fix anything, it just slows down the collabpse. The problem was never the money, it was always the design.

Leave a Reply